British big cats

In British folklore, British big cats, also referred to as ABCs (alien, or anomalous, big cats), phantom cats and mystery cats, feature in reported sightings of large felids feral in the British Isles. Many of these creatures have been described as "panthers", "pumas" or "black cats".

A sign requesting information on big cats in West Sussex.

The existence of a population of "true big cats" in Britain, especially a breeding population, is rejected by many experts[1][2] owing to a lack of convincing evidence for the presence of these animals. There have been some incidents of recovered individual animals, often medium-sized species such as the Eurasian lynx, but in one 1980 case a puma was captured alive in Scotland.[3] These are generally believed to have been escaped or released exotic pets that had been held illegally, possibly released after the animals became too difficult to manage or after the introduction of the Dangerous Wild Animals Act 1976.[4][5] Some sightings at a distance may be explicable as domestic cats seen near to a viewer being misinterpreted as larger animals seen farther away.[6][7][8]

A fringe theory suggests that the animals may be survivors from the Ice Age,[5] a time when leopards, scimitar-toothed cats, lions, and lynxes were found in the British Isles. While such animals are not known to have survived to the present, in his 2013 book Feral, George Monbiot argues that humans are programmed to notice things that might be big cats because of the threat they posed in prehistoric times.

Reported sightings

Documentation

The group Big Cats in Britain published reported sightings annually by county. The "top ten" counties or regions of Great Britain between April 2004 and July 2005 were:[9]

Region Devon Yorkshire Scotland Wales Gloucestershire Sussex Cornwall Kent Somerset Leicestershire
Number of sightings 676 127 125 123 104 103 99 92 91 89

First sightings

William Cobbett recalled in his Rural Rides how, as a boy in the 1760s, he had seen a cat "as big as a middle-sized Spaniel dog" climb into a hollow elm tree in the grounds of the ruined Waverley Abbey near Farnham in Surrey. Later, in New Brunswick, he saw a "lucifee" (North American lynx – Felis lynx canadensis) "and it seemed to me to be just such a cat as I had seen at Waverley."[10] Another report appeared in the Daily Express on 14 January 1927 of a "lynx" being seen.

The New Forest folktale of the Stratford Lyon tells of how John de Stratford pulled a giant, red, antlered lion from the ground at South Baddesley in the New Forest in the year 1400. The story is first recorded in the marginalia of an 18th-century bible. In the late 20th century, sightings of the lion were recorded in the vicinity of the Red Lion Pub, Boldre.[11]

Further back there is a medieval Welsh poem Pa Gwr in the Black Book of Carmarthen which mentions a Cath Palug, meaning "Palug's cat" or "clawing cat", which roamed Anglesey until slain by Cei. In the Welsh Triads, it was the offspring of the monstrous sow Henwen.[12]

Evidence

Captures and remains

This puma (Puma concolor) was captured in the wild, in Inverness-shire, Scotland in 1980. It is believed to have been an abandoned pet. It lived the rest of its life in a zoo. After it died, it was stuffed and placed in Inverness Museum.
The Taxidermied remains of a jungle cat (Felis chaus) killed by a car on Hayling Island

A Canadian lynx shot in Devon in 1903 is now in the collection of the Bristol Museum.[13] Analysis of its teeth suggests that prior to its death it had spent a significant amount of time in captivity.[13]

In 1980, a puma was captured in Inverness-shire, Scotland. The capture followed several years of sightings in the area of a big cat matching the description of the one captured, which had led local farmer Ted Noble to erect a cage trap. The puma was subsequently put into the Highland Wildlife Park zoo and given the name "Felicity". When it died it was stuffed and was placed in Inverness Museum.[14] Zoo director Eddie Orbell concluded that the animal had been tamed and might not have been released for long, noting that it enjoyed being tickled.[15]

In 1988, a jungle cat was killed after being hit by a car on Hayling Island.[16] The taxidermied remains ended up in the collection of Hampshire museum services.[16] A year later, 1989, a jungle cat that had been hit by a car was found on the roadside in Shropshire.[17]

In 1991, a Eurasian lynx was shot near Norwich, Norfolk. It had killed around 15 sheep within two weeks. The story was only reported in 2003, and the stuffed body of the lynx is allegedly now in the possession of a collector. For many years this incident was considered to have been a hoax, particularly by the hunting community, but in March 2006 a police report confirmed that the case was true. It was probably an escapee from a facility in the area that bred animals, including Eurasian lynxes.[18]

In 1994, it was reported that a large cat with leopard-pattern fur had been shot on the Isle of Wight some time earlier after feasting on chickens and ducks. The shooting was not immediately reported as the farm worker involved feared prosecution, but police reportedly concluded that the animal was an ocelot or serval.

There have been reports that in 1993, yet another puma was captured in Scotland, this time in the Aviemore area.[14][19]

In 1996, police in Fintona, County Tyrone, Northern Ireland shot a cat. It was reportedly a caracal, a medium-sized wildcat species found in Africa and Asia, although a police report described it as a lynx.[6][20] (Caracals are sometimes called desert lynxes, but are not true members of the genus Lynx.)[21]

In a well-reported 2001 case ("the Beast of Barnet"), a young female Eurasian lynx was captured alive by police and vets in Cricklewood, north-London, after a chase across school playing fields and into a block of flats. It was placed in London Zoo and given the name "Lara" before ultimately being transferred to a zoo in France to breed.[22][23] The captured lynx was found to be only 18 months old, although considerably larger than an average domestic cat.[6][24]

In November 2017, a trucker claimed to have seen three highways workers struggling to lift the body of a dead 4-foot (1.2 m) black panther into the back of a truck in a lay-by on the A1 near Harworth.[25] However, Highways England responded with a statement to say that it was a dead black dog that they had loaded onto the back of the truck.[25]

This list excludes escapes of short duration and known origin. Examples of this include an incident in Grimsby in 1991 when four lions managed to escape from a circus (or possibly were released) before being captured the same day.[26]

Video and photographic evidence

Around 1993, a number of reports were made of a large black cat around Bodmin Moor, nicknamed the "Beast of Bodmin", with at least two videos made. Some video evidence was examined by government scientists, who concluded from the position of the camera and animal that the sightings were of black cats no more than 30 cm (12 in) high at the shoulder.[7][8]

Twenty-one years after this a colour video at Winkworth Arboretum (NT), Busbridge next to Godalming was taken of a large cat walking away beneath a branch. A Surrey Wildlife Trust published they doubted any "puma" form as the recorder thought, but rather thought it could be an Iberian lynx, comparing other reports made that year in Surrey's Borough of Guildford. Less well noted similar accounts have been sporadically reported since 1959, but have tended to be vague or anonymous.[27]

In 1994 footage of a large black cat was recorded in Cambridgeshire and was named in the media as the "fen tiger".[28]

In June 2006 a large black cat was recorded in the countryside of Banff, Aberdeenshire. Footage of the cat was broadcast by the BBC on 24 May 2007.[29]

In July 2009, photographs and video footage of a large black cat were taken by an off-duty Ministry of Defence Police officer. The animal was walking along a railway line in Helensburgh, Argyll. Large cats, either black or tan, have been reported in the area before.[30]

In late 2009 video footage of what is claimed to be a large black cat was recorded in Herefordshire.[31] The sighting and video footage of the alleged big cat coincided with a spree of sheep killings in the same area.[32]

In 2010 video footage of what is claimed to be a large black cat was recorded in Stroud, Gloucestershire.[33] 'Experts' have estimated that the creature was at least five feet (1.5 m) in length from nose to tail.[34]

In 2011 a family walking in Fochabers Wood, Moray, photographed a large black cat matching the description of a forest jaguar.[35] In the summer of the same year, a black panther known as the "Beast of Dartmoor" was reportedly seen by a group of fifteen people, including Matthew P. Warburton, in the Haldon Forest, Devon.[36][37]

In 2013, photos were taken of what appeared to be a large black cat on the estate of Sir Benjamin Slade, 7th Baronet in Somerset.[38]

In 2017 there were five sightings of big cats in Gloucestershire, some with photographic evidence.[39]

In April 2017 a mother and her teenage daughter took several photos of what appears to have been a large black big cat in the Quantock Hills, Somerset, which was speculated by BeastWatch UK, a non-profit organisation that collates and reports on exotic wildlife, that it could have been a panther or jaguar.[40]

A 2017 documentary included footage taken by an off-duty police officer in the West Midlands of a large black cat that was analysed by a big cat expert from South Africa who concluded that it had the characteristics of a black leopard.[41] He also analysed footage taken of a large black cat in the village of Maiden Newton, Dorset and said that it was the "most conclusive evidence so far that a black leopard is on the loose in the UK".[42]

2020 saw the public locked down by Covid restrictions for large portions of the year. With people confined to their homes and restricted to local walks for recreation, this year saw a large numbers of sightings across the country. In Cambridgeshire a large leopard like cat was photographed drawing comparisons with the legendary "fen tiger".[43] Gloucestershire had numerous sightings.[44] North Wales, a known hotspot for big cats, where "It seems it's common knowledge among many local communities that a small population of big cats such as pumas exist within North Wales." had its share although it was only caught on camera once.[45] In Somerset an animal fitting the description of a melanistic leopard was seen by a number of witnesses in various places. "One person believes she has footage of a big cat and has approached a big cat expert to review her evidence."[46] In Leicestershire an animal was caught on camera.[47] A serval-like cat was photographed in North London.[48]

In 2021 in large dark coloured cat was filmed in Flintshire.[49]

Attacks

A European wildcat (Felis silvestris silvestris), the Scottish population of which is the only wild cat species known to live in Britain.

In 2000 an 11-year-old boy in Monmouthshire was attacked by what he claims was a large black cat. It left him with five long claw marks across his left cheek. The police called in a big cat expert to investigate the incident.[50]

In 2005 a man who lived in Sydenham Park in south-east London was attacked in his back garden, which backed onto a railway line. The man who was 6 ft (1.8 m) and weighed 15 stone (210 lb; 95 kg) described the cat as being a big black figure that pounced on him and was considerably stronger than he was. He was left with scratches all over his body. Police were called and according to the BBC, one police officer saw a cat the size of a Labrador dog.[51] The man who was attacked sustained scratches to his face and the alleged big cat was named locally as the "Beast of Sydenham".[52]

In 2008, it was reported that a 74 year old woman was attacked on two separate occasions by a large cat in Alness, Scottish Highlands, leaving her with injuries, but a Scottish wildcat expert concluded that it was most likely a large feral domestic cat living wild, possibly a hybrid with a Scottish wildcat, but ruled out that a Scottish wildcat itself was responsible for the attacks.[53]

In 2019 a man in Cornwall reported that a 6 ft (1.8 m) black cat attacked him through an open window and that it was trying to get in through the window.[54][55] He described it as being crossed between a domestic cat and a panther.[54][55] He was said to have reported it to the police and claimed "that they were not interested".[55]

DNA evidence

There have been conflicting reports of DNA evidence as to the existence of big cats in Britain: In 2011 it was announced by the Centre for Fortean Zoology that DNA testing, carried out by Durham University on hairs found in north-Devon, showed that a leopard was living in the area.[56] In 2012 it was announced that DNA testing on two deer carcasses found in Gloucestershire found only fox DNA, despite many locals reporting sightings and believing that the deer had been killed by a big cat.[57] In 2023, a forensic laboratory conducted DNA testing on a farm in Gloucestershire after reports of attacks on sheep and sightings throughout the COVID-19 pandemic. The DNA results came back with a 99% match to a leopard

.[58]

The Cotswolds big cat

The "Cotswolds big cat" was a purported big cat or number of big cats at large in the Cotswolds region of England.[59][60][61]

A walker in Woodchester Park found the carcass of a roe deer on 12 January 2012, with injuries suggesting the animal may have been mauled by a large felid.[59] A second similar deer carcass was found on 16 January 2012.[60]

An analysis of the deer carcasses by University of Warwick scientists only indicated DNA evidence of foxes and other deer.[62]

Government involvement

In 1988, the Ministry of Agriculture took the unusual step of sending in Royal Marines to carry out a massive search for the rumoured Beast of Exmoor after an increase in the number of mysteriously killed livestock, and farmer complaints over subsequent loss of money. Several Marines claimed to have seen the cat fleetingly, but nothing other than a fox was ever found. The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs has published a list of predatory cats that they know to have escaped in the United Kingdom, although most of these have been recaptured.[63]

In 1967 children's novelist Monica Edwards took the story on in her Punch Bowl Farm series, as The Wild One.[64]

A fictional attempt to trap the Beast is the subject of the film Young Hunters: The Beast of Bevendean (2015).[65]

The stories of British big cats have inspired a number of drinks including Exmoor Beast, a strong dark porter brewed by Exmoor Ales,[66] Beast of Bodmin a red ale made by the Firebrand Brewing Company[67] and the Dartmoor Distillery’s Dartmoor Beast Gin.[68]

Mythological explanation

For many hundreds of years the myth of the spectral Black Dog has persisted in Britain – a supposed mythical creature appearing as a large black animal in remote moorland with no firm evidence for its existence, beyond hearsay. It has been suggested that the stories of "Black Cats" are merely a modern continuation of such myths and stories, sharing the same elements but with the idea of a supernatural cause having fallen out of credibility and the modern, more plausible, idea of an escaped or released wildcat supplanting it.[69] In addition, the stories of big cats share many traits suitable for the tabloid press – as such leading to wide exposure of any potential "cat" and further and rapid dissemination of any speculation or supposed evidence for it, helping to build a widespread urban legend.

See also

Footnotes

    References

    1. Wilding, Mark (14 April 2019). "On the trail of Britain's wild big cats". The Guardian. Retrieved 19 September 2022. A spokeswoman for the Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (Defra) said: "Neither Natural England nor Defra have received any credible reports of wild living or breeding big cats in Britain in recent years. Defra is not currently engaged in any work related to the management of wild big cats in Britain and has no plans to do so."
    2. Franklin, Adrian (10 November 2016). "Far from the madding crowd: Big cats on Dartmoor and in Dorset, UK". In Hurn, Samantha (ed.). Anthropology and Cryptozoology. Routledge. ISBN 9781315567297. According to recent accounts by social scientists and environmentalists (widely supported by scientists and governmental agencies), most claims and beliefs about the presence of so-called 'alien big cats' (henceforth big cats) in Britain are largely imagined fantasies, social constructions and media-driven hysterias (Buller 2004; 2009; Monbiot 2013).
    3. Strachan, Graeme. "Big cats: The hunt for the puma caught roaming the Highlands in 1980". Press and Journal. Retrieved 30 October 2020.
    4. "Essex lion: Charting the big cats of Britain". BBC News. 28 August 2012.
    5. "Naturalist Simon King (interview)". Saturday Live. 8 August 2009. BBC Radio 4.
    6. Hambling, David (19 July 2001). "It's a lion... no it's a cat". The Guardian. Retrieved 3 September 2015.
    7. "Big cats in the UK: Fact or fiction?". BBC. Archived from the original on 22 August 2015. Retrieved 3 September 2015.
    8. Roberts, Gareth (15 December 2014). "Beast of Bodmin Moor: Mystery solved over 'beast' that slaughtered farm animals for decades". Daily Mirror. Retrieved 3 September 2015.
    9. BBC Wildlife Magazine, April 2006.
    10. Cobbett, William (2001). Rural Rides. London: Penguin. p. 204. ISBN 978-0-14043-579-5.
    11. History of the Red Lion Boldre, Christopher Tower Reference Library, Lyndhurst, 1989.
    12. "Arthur and the Porter". Celtic Literature Collective. Retrieved 28 July 2009.
    13. Morelle, Rebecca (25 April 2013). "'Big cat' Canadian lynx was on the loose in UK in 1903". BBC News. Retrieved 30 April 2013.
    14. Smith, Chris. "Felicity the Puma". Scottish Big Cat Trust. Retrieved 2 June 2012.
    15. McAllister, Bill. "Was it really a leopard that was spotted?". The Inverness Courier. Archived from the original on 24 September 2015. Retrieved 3 September 2015.
    16. Naish, Darren (17 March 2013). "Another meeting with the Hayling Island Jungle cat". Scientific American. Retrieved 15 December 2015.
    17. "Big cats in Shropshire: A tall tale or serious threat?". Shropshire Star. 12 January 2015. Retrieved 7 December 2020 via shropshirestar.com. Contains photographs
    18. "Police report solves lynx mystery". BBC News. 21 March 2006.
    19. Smith, Chris. "Second Scottish Puma". Scottish Big Cat Trust. Retrieved 2 June 2012.
    20. "'Big cat' sightings (FOI request)" (PDF). Police Service of Northern Ireland. Archived from the original (PDF) on 3 April 2014. Retrieved 3 September 2015.
    21. "Caracal facts". Big Cat Rescue. Retrieved 4 March 2015.
    22. Hewett, Chris (11 March 2014). "What became of the 'Beast of Barnet'? Times Series investigation reveals Cricklewood lynx Lara's legacy lives on". This is Local London. Retrieved 19 January 2015.
    23. O'Neill, Sean (9 May 2001). "The Beast of Cricklewood is caged". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 1 September 2010.
    24. "London Zoo rescues roaming European lynx". Scottish Big Cat Trust. Retrieved 4 June 2012.
    25. Langley, Robert (21 November 2017). "Road bosses respond to claims '4ft black panther' found on A1". lincolnshirelive.co.uk. Retrieved 17 November 2019.
    26. "Terror as four lions flee big top". Grimsby Evening Telegraph. 8 March 1991. Archived from the original on 21 April 2015. Retrieved 3 September 2015.
    27. "Is there a panther visiting Sheppey?". East Kent Gazette. 11 November 2009. Retrieved 15 April 2010.
    28. Osborne, Chris (3 April 2008). "On the tail of the tiger". BBC Cambridgeshire. Retrieved 31 May 2012.
    29. Morse, Felicity (27 August 2012). "Big cat sightings: From the beast of Bodmin to Coulport cougar, five other cat tales". Huffington Post (UK). Archived from the original on 25 April 2016. Retrieved 16 February 2014.
    30. "Policeman takes 'big cat' photo". BBC News. 28 July 2009. Retrieved 28 July 2009.
    31. "Was Herefordshire's 'big cat'" caught on camera?". Hereford Times. 16 December 2009. Retrieved 1 June 2012.
    32. Bowen, Mark (29 December 2009). "Sheep killings add to Herefordshire's big cat mystery". Hereford Times. Archived from the original on 22 March 2010. Retrieved 1 June 2012.
    33. "'Black leopard' caught on film in Stroud". The Daily Telegraph. 7 February 2012. Archived from the original on 20 May 2014. Retrieved 14 April 2014.
    34. "Video captures footage of 'big cat' in Gloucestershire". This is Gloucestershire. 7 February 2012. Archived from the original on 17 April 2012. Retrieved 1 June 2012.
    35. Crawford, Graham (7 December 2011). "Family encounters big cat in the woods". Banffshire Journal. Archived from the original on 7 April 2014. Retrieved 6 April 2014.
    36. "An encounter with the wild". embercombe.org. Retrieved 3 January 2021.
    37. "'Is there a big cat in my back yard?' (parts 1&2) and 'There IS a big cat in my back yard!' (part 3)". wildernessguide.wordpress.com. Retrieved 3 January 2021.
    38. Marsden, Sam (25 July 2013). "Aristocrat warns visitors after 'big cat' photographed on his estate". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 26 August 2019.
    39. Falconer, Ben (18 May 2018). "Five times big cats have been seen in Gloucestershire in the past year". GloucestershireLive. gloucestershirelive.co.uk. Retrieved 28 August 2018.
    40. "Beast of Somerset? Mum and daughter stunned as 'huge cat' prowls in Quantock Hills". Daily Express. 16 April 2017. Retrieved 1 January 2020.
    41. Tracking the big black cats of the UK!. Real Wild. England, UK. 31 May 2017. Event occurs at 43:05 minutes in. Retrieved 26 August 2019 via YouTube.
    42. Tracking The Big Black Cats of the UK!. Real Wild. England, UK. 31 May 2017. Event occurs at 43:05 minutes in. Retrieved 26 August 2019 via YouTube.
    43. Pengelly, Ella (13 April 2020) [11 April 2020]. "'Large wildcat with big claws' spotted in central Cambridge". Cambridgeshire Live (cambridge-news.co.uk). The 'big cat' has been compared to the size of a fully-grown Labrador dog.
    44. Horton, Kim (31 December 2020). "Top witness accounts of big cat sightings in 2020". Gloucestershire Live.
    45. Warner, Matt (28 December 2020). "These are the big cat sightings reported in North Wales in 2020". The Leader.
    46. Taylor, Michael (14 March 2020). "More big cat sightings in Somerset after woman claimed she saw one 'as large as an Alsatian' run through her garden". Somerset Live.
    47. Troughton, Adrian (20 May 2020). "Amazing video captures 'big cat' in playing field next to housing estate". Leicester Mercury.
    48. Chesters, Crystal (27 May 2020). "Here's what you need to know about Savannah cats after one was spotted in a UK garden". The Yorkshire Post. 'I saw it with my own eyes and it was not a normal pet cat'.
    49. Warner, Matt (22 February 2021). "Video footage of 'big cat' in the Flintshire countryside". The Leader.
    50. "Police 'big cat' warning". BBC News. 25 August 2000. Retrieved 2 June 2012.
    51. "'Big cat' attacks man in garden". BBC News. 22 March 2005. Retrieved 2 June 2012.
    52. Davenport, Justin (22 March 2005). "Hunt for 'beast of Sydenham'". Evening Standard. London. Retrieved 27 October 2020.
    53. "Expert tears into cat conspiracy". BBC News Online. 29 December 2008. Retrieved 28 March 2020.
    54. Shaw, Neil (18 January 2019). "Man says he was attacked through window by 6 ft big cat in Cornwall". cornwalllive.com. Retrieved 15 September 2019.
    55. "Man swiped at by 'panther-like' big cat in Cornwall". itv.com. 18 January 2019. Retrieved 15 September 2019.
    56. "Experts have DNA proof that big cats are still living in the Westcountry". This is Devon. Archived from the original on 7 March 2012. Retrieved 2 June 2012.
    57. "'Big cat' in Gloucestershire ruled out by DNA test". BBC News. 2 February 2012. Retrieved 4 June 2012.
    58. Aspinall, Adam (11 May 2023). "DNA test is 'definitive proof' huge black panthers are prowling UK countryside". mirror. Retrieved 12 May 2023.
    59. Morris, Steven (12 January 2012). "Big cat may prowl Gloucestershire wood, says National Trust". The Guardian. Retrieved 4 December 2014.
    60. Morris, Steven (16 January 2012). "Cotswolds big cat speculation mounts as second dead deer found". The Guardian. Retrieved 3 December 2014.
    61. Craig, Ian (26 February 2012). "Big cat spotted in Chelworth". Worcester News. Retrieved 3 December 2014.
    62. "Cotswolds 'big cat': No DNA evidence". BBC News. 2 February 2012. Retrieved 4 December 2014.
    63. "Reports received by Defra of escapes of non-native cats in the U.K. 1975 to present day" (PDF). Department for Environment, Food, & Rural Affairs. Archived from the original (PDF) on 10 December 2006.
    64. "The Wild One". www.goodreads.com. Retrieved 13 June 2022.
    65. "Big cat movie plan by Brighton film school tutor". The Argus. 2 February 2012. Retrieved 15 February 2013.
    66. "Exmoor Beast – Exmoor Ales". Retrieved 13 June 2022.
    67. "Beast of Bodmin". Firebrand Brewing. Retrieved 13 June 2022.
    68. "Dartmoor Beast Gin". Dartmoor Distillery. Retrieved 13 June 2022.
    69. "The Beast of Bodmin Moor". The Natural History Museum, London. Retrieved 15 February 2013.
    This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.