Consensual homicide
Consensual homicide refers to a case when one person kills another, with the consent of the person being killed.
Part of a series on |
Homicide |
---|
Murder |
Note: Varies by jurisdiction
|
Manslaughter |
Non-criminal homicide |
Note: Varies by jurisdiction |
By victim or victims |
Family |
Other |
Suicide |
---|
Assisted suicide
The most common form of consensual homicide is assisted suicide, most commonly as euthanasia, in which terminally ill people seek assistance from their doctors (or family members) to alleviate their suffering by ending their lives. This practice is legal in some jurisdictions, but remains controversial because of the legal, ethical and practical issues it raises.[1]
Exceptional cases
Suspected serial killer John Bodkin Adams claimed that his patient Edith Alice Morrell—whose murder he was tried for in 1957—had wanted to die. He was controversially found not guilty but later suspected of murdering up to 163 of his patients.[2]
In 1996 a Maryland entrepreneur named Sharon Lopatka arranged for her own torture and strangulation over the Internet.[3] In 2001, Armin Meiwes from Germany was found to have murdered and cannibalized a willing victim he found over the internet.[4] These two cases attracted considerable media attention. Beyond their lurid sexual details, both cases introduce paradoxes about the respective responsibility of the parties, the legal differences between consensual homicide and suicide.
In 2005, Japan, Hiroshi Maeue lured three people using the internet with promises to assist in their suicides, and strangled them. They may have consented to their killings at first, but the method was different from his promise of death by carbon monoxide poisoning. Maeue had previous convictions and his motivation was clearly sexual.[5] He was regarded as a serial killer and was sentenced to death.[6]
Other types
- Seppuku, the traditional Japanese method of suicide, in many cases works as consensual homicide. The assistant, called a kaishakunin, performs a mercy kill on the samurai committing suicide. If the assistant is not present, the ritual can devolve into a slow, messy death.
In popular culture
- Consensual mutual homicide of a male-female couple is the theme of Pedro Almodóvar's movie Matador. The word "matador" is traditionally used for bullfighters (also a theme of the movie), but literally means "killer".
- Consensual homicide is also a theme in the 2009 novel Dark Places, written by Gillian Flynn.
- It is also seen in the 2008 film Downloading Nancy, loosely based on the consensual murder of Sharon Lopatka by Robert Glass.
See also
References
- Betzold, Michel,"Appointment with Doctor Death" Troy, MI: Momentum Books 1996
- Cullen, Pamela V., "A Stranger in Blood: The Case Files on Dr John Bodkin Adams", London, Elliott & Thompson, 2006, ISBN 1-904027-19-9
- "A death on Usenet: Sharon Lopatka and the strange case of 'consensual murder'". The Daily Dot. July 3, 2016. Retrieved February 8, 2022.
- "German cannibal tells of fantasy". December 3, 2003. Retrieved February 8, 2022.
- "Suicide website murderer lived out his fantasies". Japan Today. August 24, 2005. Retrieved March 22, 2008.
- "Man gets death for murdering suicidal trio". The Japan Times. March 29, 2007. Retrieved February 23, 2008.