Tomb effigy
A tomb effigy, usually a recumbent effigy or, in French, gisant (French, "lying"), is a sculpted figure on a tomb monument depicting an effigy of the deceased.[1] These compositions were developed in Western Europe in the Middle Ages, and continued in use through the Renaissance and early modern period; they are still sometimes used. They typically represent the deceased in a state of "eternal repose", lying with hands folded in prayer and awaiting resurrection. A husband and wife may be depicted lying side by side.


The life-size recumbent effigy was first found in the tombs of royalty and senior clerics, and then spread to the nobility. A particular type of late medieval effigy was the transi, or cadaver monument, in which the effigy is in the macabre form of a decomposing corpse, or such a figure lies on a lower level, beneath a more conventional effigy. Mourning or weeping figures, known as pleurants were added to important tombs below the effigy. In the Early Modern period European effigies are often shown as alive, and either kneeling or in a more active pose, especially for military figures. During the Renaissance, other non-recumbent types of effigy became more popular. Variations showed the deceased lying on their side as if reading, kneeling in prayer and even standing. The recumbent effigy had something of a vogue during the Gothic revival period of the 19th century, especially for bishops and other clerics. Many graves at Monument Cemetery in Milan have recumbent figures.
Some of the best-known examples of the form are in Westminster Abbey in London, Saint Peter's in Rome, Santi Giovanni e Paolo, Venice (twenty-five Doges), and the Basilica of Santa Croce, Florence.
Antiquity
Egyptian
The religious beliefs of the societies that produced the earliest Egyptian effigies c. 2700–2200 BC (during Old Kingdom) are lost to time, but are assumed by modern archeologists to have commerated either fallen Gods or members of royalty.[2] Because these burial practices are prehistoric, their meaning can only be guessed at: modern archeologists see them as depictions intended to house the souls of the dead, intended to identify them as they travel through the realm of the dead.[2] The earliest known tomb effigy is that of Djoser (c. 2686–2613 BC), whose effigy was found in the worship chamber of an Egyptian pyramid. Usually they were smaller than life-size.
The Romans continued this tradition of idolatry, though they created many other types of effigies. Their faces are often clearly portraits of individuals.
- Replicas of the coffins of Tutankhamun, 1355–134 BC. The originals are in the Egyptian Museum, Cairo, Egypt
Etruscan
Recumbent effigies were a common tradition in the funerary art of the Etruscans, an advanced civilization and culture that developed in central Italy before 700 BC and flourished until the late second century BC.[4] Their effigies were typically carved in high relief,[4] and produced in a variety of materials, including ceramic, terracotta, marble, limestone and alabaster.[5] Structurally they fall into two categories: small squarish cinerary urns for cremation and near life-sized rectangular sarcophagi for burials, with cremation becoming more popular over the centuries.[5][6] Etruscan culture viewed the dead as no less completed than the living, and existing in a realm where they were forever in despair or forever enjoying material comforts.[5] From 500 BC the effigies perpetuated the memory of the deceased as they looked while alive, often lavishly dressed, and shown enjoying food and drink as if at a feast. They are typically shown as reclining (as if alive) rather than recumbent (as if dead), often propped on a pillow and leaning on their arm or elbow.[7]
In the 7th century the Etruscans began to depict human heads on canopic urns. When they started to bury their dead in the late 6th century, they used terracotta sarcophagi.[8] The sarcophagi were decorated with an image of the deceased reclining on the lid alone or with a spouse.[8] The Etruscan's style influenced late Ancient Greek funerary sculpture, especially in the manner of showing the dead as they had been in life, typically in the stele (stone or wooden slabs usually built as funerary markers) format.[9] Any aspects of the style were adapted by the Romans, and eventually spread as far as Western Asia.[7]
- Sarcophagus of the Spouses, 530–510 BC. National Etruscan Museum, Rome, Italy
- Sarcophagus in the Villa Corsini, Florence. 300-275 BC
- Funerary urn, c. 210–90 BC. Museo archeologico nazionale Siena, Italy
- Sarcophagus of Seianti Hanunia Tlesnasa, c. 150–130 BC. Painted terracotta, British Museum, London
Roman
The Romans adopted the Etruscan's tomb effigy formats, while still not yet showing the person commerated as being dead. They introduced a more a contemplative, spiritual and redemptive iconographical tone, emphasising the deceased's hierarchical role in society while alive.[10] Pre-historic Romans often cremated their dead, usually on a pyre, but later began to entomb the bodies while burning an effigy. The introduction of Christianity and its idea of the resurrections lead to a move away from creation in favour of burial.[5]
Medieval
Origin and characteristics
Romanesque tombs were produced in great numbers –especially in England and France– but over half were destroyed in later centuries during successive waves of iconoclasm in the early modern period, with further losses during the French revolution.[11]
he first life-sized, recumbent Medieval effigies (gisants) were produced in the 11th century. While the earliest examples are German,[12] the style was largely developed by French sculptors in the Romanesque style, during a period can ranges from c. 1080 to c. 1160.[13] By the 12th century, the German, Dutch, Belgian, Spanish effigies were following the forms and iconography of the French models,[11][13] when the middle of that century were adapting elements of the developing Gothic style.[14]
The 11th and 12th century European effigies were typically carved in low relief and were created for royalty and senior clerics. They show the deceased as they appeared as in life, with no signs of illness or death. The faces are idealised rather than accurate portrayals of the deceased, and often showed them much younger than they had been at death.[15] Gradually these became full high-relief effigies, usually recumbent as if dead and by the 14th century with hands together in prayer. The tombs and effigies were carved in stone, marble or wood, or cast in bronze or brass. Often the stone effigies were painted to simulate life, but this has long since worn away in the majority of surviving examples.
The first secular effigies appear in the early 13th century.[16] They were by then usually placed on flat marble slabs, supported by tomb-style chests (also known as tumba)[9] decorated with foliage, heraldry and architectural detailing.
- Effigy of Berengaria of Navarre (d. 1230). L'Épau Abbey
- ThirteenthTomb of Jean d'Aluye, French, 13th century. The Cloisters, New York[17]
Court of Burgundy
_-_Mus%C3%A9e_des_Beaux-Arts_-_Tombeaux_des_ducs_de_Bourgogne_(c%C3%A9notaphe_de_Philippe-le-Hardi)_(14773660169).jpg.webp)
The dukes of Burgundy were recognised throughout Europe as patrons of the arts, who through their cultivation of artists such as the sculptor Claus Sluter and the painters Jan van Eyck and Rogier van der Weyden (Rogier is thought to have painted some of the effigies), became key in the development of Early Netherlandish art and the wider Northern Renaissance.[18]
The iconography of Burgundian tombs develops forms and motifs found on monuments for French Kings in the Basilica of Saint-Denis, near Paris.[19] Although the now lost tomb of Joan of Brabant (c. 1457) is probably the earliest of the tombs,[20] the style became influential across Europe with the tomb of Philip the Bold (d. 1404), built over 30 years from 1381[21] by the sculptors Jean de Marville (d. 1389) and Sluter (d. 1405?) for the Chartreuse de Champmol, outside Dijon, which also houses the tombs of his son John the Fearless (d. 1419) and John's wife Margaret of Bavaria (d. 1424).[22][23] Philip's tomb is described by the art historian Frits Scholten as "one of the most magnificent tombs of the Late Middle Ages".[23]
The effigies on Burgundian-style tombs are characteristised by the deceased having naturalised faces, open eyes, angels above their heads, and animals (that may be dogs or lions) at their feet.[20] Philip's is made from polychromed white marble which gives him a more naturalised pallor. His head rests on a cushion and he has an angel at each side to watch over him, presumably guiding him into the afterlife. His open eyes are intended as an affirmation of his belief in the Resurrection, as are the prayers mouthed or in the books held by some of the weepers in the niches below the tomb monument's oblong chest.[24]
- Isabella of Bourbon's effigy displayed with its 10 surviving pleurants
Britain

Tomb effigies are the most numerous type of surviving English medieval statuary, and although England when through similar periods of iconoclasm, their number exceeds even that of France.[26] The large-scale production of British effigies began in the middle of the 13th century, as the result of the creation of a new patron class of knights, who although they were fewer than before, had become more wealthy.[27] A great number of ecclesiastical effigies were also produced in this period, but a majority were destroyed during both the iconoclasm waves and the Cromwellion Wars of the Three Kingdoms.[16]
Compared to French examples, the English 13th century knightly effigies are less rigid or statuesque, and have been described as reflecting a "more worldly and less spiritual outlook".[11] Three 13th century solid oak examples survive: in Pitchford (for John de Pitchford), Westminster Abbey (for William de Valence) and Salisbury Cathedral (for William Longespée).[28]
The cross-legged pose of many 13th or early 14th century English effigies was long supposed to imply that the deceased had served in the Crusades, had taken crusading vows, or more specifically had been a Knight Templar; but these theories are now rejected by scholars.[29]
- Effigy in carved wood of a recumbent knight, c. 1280-1300. Southwark Cathedral, London
- Oak tomb of Sir John de Pitchford (d. 1285). Pitchford, England
- Effigy of a Norman knight, St. John's Church, Danbury, Essex, England
- Cadaver effigy of John FitzAlan (died 1435). Arundel Castle, Sussex, England
Cadaver monuments (Transi)
A late medieval fashion was to show the person in an advanced state of decomposition. This type of tomb is known as a Cadaver monument (or transi), intended as a memento mori, and show the human body's "transition" from life to decomposition.[30]
Cadaver monuments were a dramatic departure from the typical practice of depicting the deceased as either they were in life, or in an idealised form.[31] The impulse toward graphic expression of mortality reflects the societal shock, trauma and upheaval following the Black Death which hit Europe in 1346 and killed up to half of the population of Eurasia in the next four years. It's aftermath saw a general emphasis on the macabre and Memento mori; reflecting a pre-occupation with the brevity and uncertainty of human life.[32]
- The early, influential example; gisant of Guillaume de Harsigny, c. 1394. Musée d'art et d'archéologie de Laon, France
- Detail from the Cadaver Tomb of René of Chalon, c. 1545–47. Musée du Louvre
- Effigy of Philippa of Guelders (d. 1547). Convent of Pont-à-Mousson, France
Renaissance
The innovations of Renaissance sculpture are reflected in early sixteenth century developments in funerary art. While the structural format of the effigies stayed faithful to the earlier Romanesque and Gothic traditions, the iconography began to indicate a societal shift in attitude towards the dead; a move away from Medieval Christianity towards secular and humanistic depictions of the dead, with the effigies presenting unidealised depictions of the deceased, a trend that later developed, especially in France into Cadaver monument, which focused on the macabre and the reality of rotting flesh.[33]
- Effigy of Anne Seymour, Duchess of Somerset (d. 1587) in Westminster Abbey, London
- A baroque elaboration: the tomb of Cardinal Richelieu, c. 1675-94. Chapel of the Sorbonne, Paris
Modern
The recumbent effigy had returned to vogue during the 19th century Gothic revival period of the 19th century, especially for clerics. Many graves at Monument Cemetery in Milan have recumbent figures.
A celebrated poem describing and reflecting on a pair of stone effigies is An Arundel Tomb (1956) by the English poet Philip Larkin.[34]
- Tomb of Francesc Farreras i Framis, 1888. Montjuïc Cemetery, Barcelona, Spain
- Tomb of Augustine Trochery, Cimetière Carnot, Suresnes, France
References
- Lucie-Smith, Edward (1984), The Thames and Hudson Dictionary of Art Terms, Thames and Hudson, pg 89.
- Panofsky (1964), p. 9
- "Coffin of Nesykhonsu c. 976–889 BC". Cleveland Museum of Art. Retrieved 28 April 2023
- Hemingway, Colette; Hemingway, Seán. "Etruscan Art". NYC: Metropolitan Museum of Art, October 2004. Retrieved 5 May 2023
- Panofsky (1964), p. 28
- Turfa (2005), p. 55
- Panofsky (1964), p. 29
- Ramage (2009), p. 51
- Panofsky (1964), p. 27
- Panofsky (1964), p. 30
- Tummers (1980), p. 2
- Tummers (1980), p. 3
- Fozi (2021), p. 2
- Fozi (2021), pp. 2, 4
- Fozi (2021), p. 1
- Tummers (1980), p. 4
- "A Knight of the d'Aluye Family". Metropolitan Museum of Art. Retrieved 10 May 2023
- Lee Reid, Katerrine. In the preface to Antoine (2005)
- Jugie (2010), p. 39
- Jugie (2010), p. 51
- Antoine (2005), p. 419
- Nash (2008), pp. 262–263
- Scholten (2007), p. 14
- Jugie (2010), p. 31
- Jugie (2019), p. 47
- Tummers (1980), pp. 1–2
- Stone (1972), p. 114
- Tummers (1980), p. 30
- Harris, O. D. (2010). "Antiquarian attitudes: crossed legs, crusaders and the evolution of an idea". Antiquaries Journal. 90: 401–40. doi:10.1017/s0003581510000053. S2CID 206212438.
- Cohen (1973), p. 179
- Heimerman, Emily (April 2, 2021). "A Portrait of Death: Analyzing the Transi Tomb of Guillaume de Harcigny (1300–1393 A.D.)". The Coalition of Master's Scholars on Material Culture.
- Roe (1969), p. 1
- Panofsky (1964), pp. 67, 79
- Booth, James. Philip Larkin: Life, Art and Love. London: Bloomsbury, 2014. p. 214. ISBN 978-1-4088-5166-1
- "Tomb Effigy of Elizabeth Boott Duveneck". Metropolitan Museum of Art. Retrieved 28 April 2023
Sources

- Antoine, Elisabeth. Art from the Court of Burgundy: The Patronage of Philip the Bold and John the Fearless, 1364-1419. Seattle (WA): University of Washington, 2005. ISBN 978-2-7118-4864-5
- Fozi, Shirin. Romanesque Tomb Effigies: Death and Redemption in Medieval Europe, 1000–1200. University Park (PA): Penn State University Press, 2021. ISBN 978-0-2710-8917-1
- Fryer, Alfred Cooper. "Wooden Monumental Effigies In England And Wales". London: Archaeologia or Miscellaneous Tracts relating to Antiquity, 1909, republished 1924
- Jugie, Sophie. Le Tombeau de Philippe Pot. Paris: Ediciones El Viso, 2019. ISBN 978-8-4948-2447-0
- Jugie, Sophie. The Mourners: Tomb Sculpture from the Court of Burgundy. New Haven (CT): Yale University Press, 2010. ISBN 978-0-3001-5517-4
- Cohen, Kathleen. The Changing Meaning of the Transi Tomb in Fifteenth and Sixteenth-Century Europe. Berkeley and Los Angeles (CA): University of California Press, 1968
- Panofsky, Irvin. Tomb Sculpture: Four Lectures on its Changing Aspects from Ancient Egypt to Bernini. London: Harry Abrams, 1964. ISBN 978-0-8109-3870-0
- Smith, Jeffrey Chipps. The Northern Renaissance. London: Phaidon Press, 2004. ISBN 978-0714838670
- Stone, Lawrence, Sculpture in Britain: The Middle Ages, 1972 (2nd edn.), Penguin Books (now Yale History of Art)
- Ramage, Nancy; Ramage, Andrew. Roman Art: Romulus to Constantine. NJ: Pearson Prentice-Hall, 2009
- Roe, Helen. "Cadaver Effigial Monuments in Ireland". Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland, volume 99, No. 1, 1969. p. 4. JSTOR 25509699
- S'Jacob, Henriette Eugénie. Idealism and Realism: A Study of Sepulchral Symbolism. University of Michigan: E.J. Brill, 1954
- Tummers, H.A. Early Secular Effigies in England: The Thirteenth Century. Leiden: Brill Archive, 1980. ISBN 978-9-0040-6255-9
- Turfa, Jean Macintosh. Catalogue of the Etruscan Gallery of the University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology. Philadelphia (PA): University of Pennsylvania Press, 2005. ISBN 978-1-9317-0752-7