Graham Baldwin
Graham Baldwin (born c. 1954)[1] is a British anti-cult activist who formed and directs the organization Catalyst Counseling, commonly called Catalyst, which received charity status in Britain in 1995.[2][3] Catalyst primarily provides "exit counseling" to ex-cultists, but occasionally Baldwin would be consulted for news organizations, court cases, etc.[4][5] Baldwin received a Bachelor's degree in divinity from King's College and was a chaplain at the University of London.[6][7] Baldwin has been called an "exit counsellor" by some newspapers like The Times and The Telegraph.[8][9][10]
Catalyst and anti-cult activity
Baldwin has been the director of Catalyst since its formation in late 1993.[11] Catalyst offers exit counseling services to former members of new religious movements.[11] Baldwin and Catalyst do not support deprogramming on its surface but have been accused of doing it anyway.[6][12][13]
Baldwin began exit counseling at King's College London, where he was a chaplain,[6] when the a group called the London Church of Christ started to evangelize on campus. The group expelled some members in March 1993 in line with a supposed policy of recruiting rich, white people as opposed to black and poor white people.[6] About 30 former members and Baldwin sued the Church for defamation and financial impropriety in September 1993.[6]
In 1997, Baldwin traveled to Portugal to help retrieve some children from a new religious movement for a British woman (see below).
In July 2000, Baldwin was involved in an incident with the Jesus Christians and their supposed kidnapping of Bobby Kelly, a British 16-year-old who met some Jesus Christians at a shopping mall.[14][15] The exact details of the incident are disputed; the Jesus Christians and Kelly himself argue that not only was he not kidnapped from his grandmother, his legal guardian at the time, but that they encouraged him to go home since he was only sixteen.[16][17] His grandmother, in an article in the Daily Express, attested that the Jesus Christians told him to give up everything including family.[18] On 27 July 2000, Bobby Kelly was identified as an inhabitant of a tent in a forest on the Surrey-Hampshire border near Mytchett.[15] The two people who originally made contact with Kelly, Susan (Sue) and Roland Gianstefani, were sentenced to six-month suspended sentences for their part in the "kidnapping."[15] In a note that he passed to the judge who handed down the sentence, Kelly wrote that they were protecting him against Baldwin, who they perceived was dangerous.[15][19][20] The leader of the Jesus Christians, David McKay, and other Jesus Christians believed that Catalyst and Baldwin were trying to deprogram Kelly.[21][22] Media producer Jon Ronson attempted to cover the story in an article in The Guardian in January 2006; however, it was never published because of Baldwin's presence in the article and his previous libel actions against the newspaper. Ronson provided the Jesus Christians access to the manuscript which is now available to view on their website with their commentary.[23]
Libel actions against The Guardian
In 1986, Mark Scott obtained custody of three children from his ex-wife, Claire Scott. Mark and Claire were members of the International Saturday Group (ISG), based in Areia, Portugal, led by Mark's mother Nadine Scott.[24][25] Claire Scott left the group and moved to Britain in 1987 after her and Mark's divorce.[25] Mark died of an AIDS-related illness in 1997,[26] and a Portuguese court awarded her custody of their children on the condition that Claire Scott does not leave Portugal.[24] She flew to Portugal for her ex-husband's funeral and learned from Nadine Scott that another member of ISG would foster the children.[25] Wishing to bring her children to Britain, Claire Scott made contact with Baldwin through Catalyst and asked for assistance in bringing the then pre-teen children to Britain. Baldwin agreed, since Catalyst believed that the group was a "cult" that used poverty and physical force to control its members, and flew to Portugal.[24] The details of what happened after Baldwin's arrival are unclear. His arrival to ISG's location was allegedly unannounced.[25] The three children—a sixteen-year-old girl and two 13-year-old twin boys—expressed to both Claire Scott and Baldwin that they wished to stay in Portugal with ISG, but were forced to leave to Britain, where they arrived on 16 January 1997.[24][27]
On 23 January 1997, The Guardian published a article called "Into a Shadowy World" in which the authors portrayed Baldwin as a "self-promoting, obsessive and dangerous" person against new religious movements.[25][28] Baldwin brought the newspaper and the authors to the High Court in London charging them with defamation. Baldwin believed that his characterization was libelous in addition to the article's assertion that he broke a pledge made with Portuguese court, used false religious credentials, and was involved in the children's deprogramming.[29][30] On 20 November 1998, a jury decided that the article defamed Baldwin.[30] Baldwin was awarded £15,000 plus costs in damages for the article's libelous assertions.[30]
The Guardian's editor Alan Rusbridger believed that the newspaper article was a "responsible and careful piece of journalism" and that losing the case was a "sad reflection on the libel laws."[30] Rusbridger reported that The Guardian would appeal the decision;[30] however, Baldwin believed that the editor's comments "undermine[d] the vindication he had won from the jury" in the original case, according to journalist Duncan Lamont.[31] Baldwin brought The Guardian back to court for a second libel action. The Guardian argued that it and Rusbridger were protected under qualified privilege since it was for the public interest. However, in July 2001 Judge David Eady determined that they could not use that defense.[31][32] Rusbridger and The Guardian paid Baldwin more damages in a settlement made on 31 January 2002.[33][34]
See also
References
- Gillan, Audrey, "Anti-cult campaigner 'devastated' by article," The Guardian (London), 11 November 1998.
- Arweck, Elisabeth, Researching New Religious Movements: Responses and Redefinitions (London and New York: Routledge, 2006), 194n30.
- "Catalyst Counselling - About Us". www.catalystcounselling.org.uk. Retrieved 2022-08-07.
- Mendick, Robert, "Boy not with us, says cult," The Independent on Sunday (London), 16 July 2000.
- Schaefer, Nancy A., "An American 'Faith Healer' in Britain: Another Moral Panic?," Journal of American Culture 23, no. 3 (2000): 1–15. p. 10.
- Sanders, Claire "Cult sued by former chaplain," The Times Higher Education Supplement (London), 10 September 1993.
- Baldwin, Graham in "Jacob Prasch & Moriel Under Investigation," YouTube, 16 December 2018, retrieved 12 June 2022.
- Flusfeder, David, "Own goals and penalties," The Times (London), 28 May 1994.
- The Times (London). No Title. 11 March 2000. The article is a review and discussion of the film Holy Smoke! (2000), a film controversially depicting an exit counselling session.
- Wallis, Lynne, "'How I Got Stuck in a Cult,'" The Telegraph (London), 5 February 2012.
- Arweck, Researching New Religious Movements, 194n30.
- Gillan, Audrey, "Jury is asked: was article fair?," The Guardian (London), 19 November 1998.
- Gillan, Audrey, "Paper accused over story on cults opponent," The Guardian (London), 10 November 1998.
- Hendry, Alex, "Search for Missing Cult Boy," BBC News (London), 14 July 2000.
- Reid, Tim and Urquhart, Coral, "Missing boy found safe and well," The Times (London), 28 July 2000.
- "Cult Kidnap Boy," Jesus Christians, retrieved 12 June 2022.
- Bobby Kelly in Jon Ronson, director, Kidneys for Jesus (2000). Clip reproduced on YouTube. Retrieved 12 June 2022.
- Hendry, Alex, "Cult Kidnap Boy Aged 16," Daily Express (London), 14 July 2000.
- Dixon, Cyril, "Cult boy Bobby tried to recruit 12-year-old best friend," Daily Express (London), 28 July 2000.
- Maguire, Fergus, "Newcastle sect pair face court," The Newcastle Herald, 28 July 2000.
- Mullins, Andrew, "Police find boy hiding with sect in forest," The Independent (London), 28 July 2000.
- Ronson, Jon, "I wasn't brainwashed, but enlightened," London Evening Standard, 12 October 2000.
- "Jon Ronson Tells The Truth About Bobby Kelly". jesuschristians.com. 27 January 2006. Retrieved 2022-08-07.
- Daniels, Alison, "Mother returns to Britain with children saved from cult 'family,'" The Guardian (London), 17 January 1997.
- Gillan, Audrey, "Paper accused over story on cults opponent," The Guardian (London), 10 November 1998.
- Gillan, Audrey, "Anti-cult director 'made children leave Portugal,'" The Guardian (London), 17 November 1998.
- Gillan, Audrey, "Children returned to UK in 'brutal and frightening' way," The Guardian (London), 18 November 1998.
- Hooper, John and Bunting, Madeleine, "Into a Shadowy World," The Guardian (London), 23 January 1997. Please note that this article was proved defaming in a court of law.
- Gillan, Audrey, "Jury is asked: was article fair?," The Guardian (London), 19 November 1998.
- Gillan, Audrey, "Anti-cult man wins libel case," The Guardian (London), 21 November 1998.
- Lamont, Duncan, "Fight the good fight?: The dangers of repeating a libel," Press Gazette (London), 23 August 2001.
- "No privilege for journalists in replying to criticisms made in court," The Times (London), 23 July 2001.
- Pearson, Roger, "Guardian hit by double damages," Press Gazette (London), 31 January 2002.
- "In Brief: Mr Graham Baldwin," The Guardian (London), 4 February 2002.