United States v. Google LLC (2020)

United States v. Google LLC is an ongoing federal antitrust case brought by the United States Department of Justice (DOJ) against Google LLC on October 20, 2020. The suit alleges that Google has violated the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 through anti-competitive behavior in the search engine and search advertising markets.[1]

For other uses, see United States v. Google.
United States v. Google LLC
CourtUnited States District Court for the District of Columbia
Full case nameUnited States, State of Arkansas, State of Florida, State of Georgia, State of Indiana, Commonwealth of Kentucky, State of Louisiana, State of Mississippi, State of Missouri, State of Montana, State of South Carolina and State of Texas v. Google LLC
StartedOctober 20, 2020
Court membership
Judge(s) sittingAmit P. Mehta

The lawsuit has been described as the most important federal antitrust lawsuit since the 1998 United States v. Microsoft Corp..[2] The case is expected to go to trial in September 2023.[3] The DOJ filed a second antitrust lawsuit against Google over the company's advertising market practices in 2023.[4]

Background

The rapid growth of the U.S. tech industry in the 1990s led to concerns about potential for anti-competitive behavior in the sector.[5] This ultimately led to the federal government launching an antitrust suit against Microsoft, alleging that the company unfairly hindered competition.[2]

In the 2010s, concerns about potential anti-competitive behavior by "Big Tech" (Google, Apple, Amazon, Facebook) companies were became subject to lawmaker scrutiny. On October 6, 2020, the Democratic majority staff on the House Judiciary Subcommittee on Antitrust, Commercial and Administrative Law released a nearly 450-page report following a 16-month long investigation concluding that the companies wield "monopoly power".[6]

Prior antitrust scrutiny of Google

In 2008, scrutiny from the Department of Justice (DOJ) and the Canadian Competition Bureau scrutiny of an advertising deal between Google and Yahoo! led the companies to abandon their agreement. According to the DOJ, the "agreement between these two companies accounting for 90 percent or more of each relevant market" would have likely harmed "competition in the markets for Internet search advertising and Internet search syndication".[7]

The DOJ lawsuit alleges that Google Search holds an unlawful monopoly in the search engine market

In 2011, members of the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) voted to demand information from Google as part of an antitrust inquiry into the company's search engine practices. Following a nineteen-month investigation, FTC staff attorneys recommended that the agency bring forth an antitrust lawsuit against Google. However, the members of the commissioners ultimately declined this recommendation, and voted on January 3, 2013, to close the investigation.[8]

During the 2010s, the European Commission engaged in antitrust scrutiny of Google, leading to the company being found guilty of competition law breaches in three separate cases.[9] The United States v. Google lawsuit has been specifically compared to the European Commission's lawsuit against Google's Android practices.[10]

Allegations

In United States v. Google LLC, the federal government alleges that Google has unfairly hindered competition in the search market through anti-competitive deals with Apple as well as mobile carriers.[11] The government alleges that, as a result of these practices, Google has accumulated control of around 88% of the domestic search engine market.

In doing so, the government alleges, Google has additionally monopolized the search advertising market at the expense of competing services.[12] Per the government's estimation, Google has been able to accumulate control of over 70% of the search advertising market.[2] As a result of lack of competition, Google has been able to over-charge advertisers versus what they would pay in a competitive environment.[13]

Proceedings
Jonathan Kanter (pictured) succeeded Makan Delrahim, who served under Trump, as Assistant Attorney General for the Antitrust Division in 2021.

The Department of Justice (DOJ) formally brought the case on October 20, 2020, in conjunction with state attorneys general representing the following states: Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, South Carolina, and Texas.[1] Makan Delrahim, then serving as Assistant Attorney General for the DOJ Antitrust Division, had recused himself during the probe earlier in the year due to his past professional work for Google.[14] It was reported in December 2020 that the trial would likely begin on September 12, 2023.[3]

Following the confirmation of Jonathan Kanter as Assistant Attorney General for the DOJ Antitrust Division, Google questioned Kanter's impartiality in the case given his past work for rival companies.[15] Constitutional scholar Laurence Tribe criticized Google's claims, arguing they have "little legal basis and strain common sense".[16] In May 2022, it was reported that Kanter would be barred from working on the case as the DOJ considers mandating his recusal.[17] Kanter was ultimately cleared by the DOJ to participate in the department's scrutiny of Google in January 2023.[18]

Owing to the accusation that Google engaged in anti-competitive conduct through exclusivity dealings with Apple, it was reported in February 2022 that the government is looking to depose "Apple's most senior executives".[19]

On December 12, 2022, Google asked the court to toss out the case, arguing that it fairly achieved its dominant market share and that the DOJ's argument "relies on dubious antitrust arguments."[20] In 2023, the DOJ accused Google of destroying evidence relevant to the lawsuit.[21]

Analysis

The case has attracted public interest amid both domestic and international scrutiny of the four Big Tech companies. United States v. Google LLC has been compared to the United States v. Microsoft Corp. (2002), a noted antitrust case against Microsoft.[22]

According to John Newman of the University of Miami School of Law, "U.S. v. Google might be the first big case against Big Tech, but it likely won't be the last."[23] Two months after United States v. Google was filed, the FTC would bring on an antitrust case against Facebook.[24]

Public opinion

Polling by advocacy group Demand Progress in October 2020 found that respondents across party lines support the suit by a 48% to 36% margin, with 52% of Republicans and 49% of Democrats found to be in support.[25] A survey of tech workers at various firms conducted by workplace app Blind in October 2020 found that 57% of tech employees polled believe the suit has merit, though only 13% of Google workers said the same.[26]

Response from officials

Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) praised the DOJ for bringing forth a "legitimate, long-time-coming suit against Google for engaging in anti-competitive, manipulative, and often illegal conduct".[27] Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX) also praised the lawsuit, arguing that "Google abuses its power not just in the search market by using its monopoly power to make billions, but it also uses it to try to censor the American People".[28]

Eric Schmidt, formerly CEO of both Google and parent company Alphabet Inc., criticized the lawsuit, stating that "There's a difference between dominance and excellence".[29]

In December 2020, a coalition of 38 states brought on a similar lawsuit against Google. Co-led by Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser, the State of Colorado et al. v. Google LLC[30] case reportedly "goes beyond the DOJ's" in its scope of accusations, according to CNBC.[31]

In July 2021, a coalition of attorneys general from 36 states and the District of Columbia launched an antitrust lawsuit alleging that Google has hindered competition in the app market through its Google Play store policies.[32] In March 2022, it was reported that the DOJ was in the process of investigating if Google has engaged in anti-competitive conduct through bundling its Google Maps service with company software.[33]

In January 2023, the DOJ filed a second antitrust suit against Google, centering on alleged anti-competitive conduct in the advertising technology (adtech) market.[34] A spokesperson for Google denied the allegations of the lawsuit and accused the DOJ of trying to "pick winners and losers in the highly competitive advertising technology sector.”[35]

Reportedly pending future lawsuits

In addition to both ongoing federal antitrust lawsuits against Google, it was reported in February 2023 that the DOJ is probing Google Maps in preparation for a potential third lawsuit. According to Politico, the probe focuses on the Google Automotive Services (GAS) offering provided to automakers, which includes the Maps service, the Play store, and Google's voice assistant. The probe also scrutinizes Google's control of location data through Google Maps.[36]

See also

References
  1. "Justice Department Sues Monopolist Google For Violating Antitrust Laws". Department of Justice. 2020-10-20. Retrieved 2022-05-29.
  2. Feiner, Lauren (2020-10-20). "Google sued by DOJ in antitrust case over search dominance". CNBC. Retrieved 2022-05-30.
  3. Feiner, Lauren (2020-12-18). "DOJ case against Google likely won't go to trial until late 2023, judge says". CNBC. Retrieved 2022-05-30.
  4. Feiner, Lauren (2023-01-24). "DOJ files second antitrust suit against Google, seeks to break up its ad business". CNBC. Retrieved 2023-03-24.
  5. Swartz, Jon. "Big Tech heads for 'a year of thousands of tiny tech papercuts,' but what antitrust efforts could make them bleed?". MarketWatch. Retrieved 2022-05-30.
  6. Feiner, Lauren (2020-10-06). "House Democrats say Facebook, Amazon, Alphabet, Apple enjoy 'monopoly power' and recommend big changes". CNBC. Retrieved 2022-05-30.
  7. "#08-981: Yahoo! Inc. and Google Inc. Abandon Their Advertising Agreement (2008-11-05)". www.justice.gov. Retrieved 2022-05-30.
  8. Nylen, Leah. "How Washington fumbled the future". POLITICO. Retrieved 2022-05-29.
  9. Feiner, Lauren (2020-12-18). "Google's antitrust mess: Here are all the major cases it's facing in the U.S. and Europe". CNBC. Retrieved 2022-05-29.
  10. Bergqvist, Christian (2020-11-12). "What the Department of Justice Can Learn from the European Union's Antitrust Investigations Into Google". ProMarket. Retrieved 2022-05-30.
  11. Kang, Cecilia; McCabe, David; Wakabayashi, Daisuke (2020-10-20). "U.S. Accuses Google of Illegally Protecting Monopoly". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2022-05-29.
  12. Bokat-Lindell, Spencer (2020-10-22). "Opinion | The Case Against Google". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2022-05-29.
  13. Kendall, Brent (October 21, 2020). "U.S. v. Google: A Guide to the Government's Lawsuit". The Wall Street Journal.
  14. Rund, Jacob; Holland, Jake; Beyoud, Lydia (October 21, 2020). "DOJ Trots Out Corporate, Tech Veterans in Google Antitrust Probe". Bloomberg Law. Retrieved 2022-05-29.
  15. "Google, Backed by Hogan Lovells, Asks DOJ to Investigate Kanter Recusal". National Law Journal. Retrieved 2022-05-29.
  16. Tribe, Laurence (2022-02-01). "Google's Calls for Jonathan Kanter's Recusal Are Baseless". ProMarket. Retrieved 2022-05-29.
  17. Nylen, Leah (2022-05-10). "Antitrust Chief Barred From Google Cases Amid Recusal Push". Bloomberg.com. Retrieved 2022-05-29.
  18. Sisco, Josh (2023-01-13). "DOJ antitrust chief cleared to oversee Google probes". POLITICO. Retrieved 2023-03-31.
  19. "Top Apple executives likely to be deposed in U.S. fight with Google". Reuters. 2022-02-11. Retrieved 2022-05-30.
  20. Bartz, Diane (2022-12-13). "Google asks court to toss out federal antitrust lawsuit". Reuters. Retrieved 2022-12-14.
  21. Michaels, Dave (2023-02-23). "Justice Department Says Google Destroyed Evidence Related to Antitrust Lawsuit". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 2023-03-31.
  22. Rosoff, Matt (2020-10-20). "DOJ case against Google has strong echoes of Microsoft antitrust case". CNBC. Retrieved 2022-05-30.
  23. Carreras, Daniela (October 21, 2020). "United States v. Google LLC: Cracking Down on Big Tech". University of Miami Law Review.
  24. Kang, Cecilia; Isaac, Mike (2020-12-09). "U.S. and States Say Facebook Illegally Crushed Competition". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2022-05-29. The investigations already led to a lawsuit against Google, brought by the Justice Department two months ago, that accuses the search giant of illegally protecting a monopoly.
  25. Gold, Ashley (2020-10-28). "Exclusive: Poll shows bipartisan support for tech antitrust action". Axios. Retrieved 2022-05-30.
  26. Levitsky, Allison (October 21, 2020). "Lots of tech employees say Google anti-trust action has merit. Google workers say otherwise". Silicon Valley Business Journal. Retrieved 2022-05-30.
  27. Kafka, Peter (2020-10-20). "Bill Barr and Elizabeth Warren find a common enemy: Google". Vox. Retrieved 2022-05-30.
  28. Sozzi, Brian (October 21, 2020). "Senator Ted Cruz: Big tech companies like Google are 'drunk on power'". Yahoo! Finance. Retrieved 2022-05-30.
  29. Copeland, Rob (October 21, 2020). "Former Google CEO Fires Back at Justice Department's Antitrust Suit". The Wall Street Journal.
  30. Perlman, Matthew (December 17, 2020). "Google Hit With 3rd Monopolization Suit". Law360. Retrieved 2022-05-29. The case is State of Colorado et al. v. Google LLC, case number 1:20-cv-03715, in the U.S. District Court for District of Columbia.
  31. Feiner, Lauren (2020-12-17). "Google hit with its third antitrust lawsuit since October, this time by a bipartisan coalition of states". CNBC. Retrieved 2022-05-29.
  32. Feiner, Lauren (2021-07-07). "States bring a new antitrust suit against Google over its mobile app store". CNBC. Retrieved 2022-05-29.
  33. Bartz, Diane; Dave, Paresh (2022-03-30). "Exclusive: U.S. probe of Google Maps picks up speed". Reuters. Retrieved 2022-05-29.
  34. Feiner, Lauren. "DOJ files second antitrust lawsuit against Google". CNBC. Retrieved 2023-01-24.
  35. Kruppa, Miles; Schechner, Sam; Michaels, Dave (2023-01-24). "DOJ Sues Google, Seeking to Break Up Online Advertising Business". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 2023-03-31.
  36. Sisco, Josh (2023-02-22). "DOJ pushes ahead with Google Maps antitrust probe". POLITICO. Retrieved 2023-04-02.
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.